Important: a trading company is not automatically a problem, and a factory is not automatically a good supplier. The aim is to know which entity makes your goods, who is accountable for quality, and what the price includes. This guide is commercial sourcing information, not legal or certification advice.
Why the distinction matters
Three practical decisions depend on it. First, price: a margin may be reasonable for consolidation and communication, but you should know it exists. Second, quality responsibility: if production is subcontracted, the party you paid may not control the line. Third, verification: an audit of a sales office tells you nothing about the workshop.
Some suppliers describe themselves as a factory because buyers ask for one. Others genuinely manufacture one product line and trade the rest. Both situations are manageable once the claim is made specific: which legal entity, which address, which product, which equipment.
5 checks you can do from your desk
- Read the business scope on the licence. A Chinese business licence lists a registered scope. Wording about manufacturing or production of your product category supports a factory claim; wording limited to sales, wholesale, trade or import/export suggests a trading entity. Ask for the original-language version as well as any translation.
- Compare the unified social credit code across documents. The code on the licence should connect to the company named on the proforma invoice, the contract and the bank beneficiary. If three different entities appear, ask for a written explanation of each role before you pay.
- Look at the registered address. An industrial park, a plant address or a named production zone is a different signal from a serviced office, a floor in a commercial tower, or a mail-box address. Check whether the address on the licence, the website, the invoice and the email signature agree.
- Ask order-specific production questions. A real production site can usually answer tolerances, material grades, tooling ownership, minimum batch constraints, lead-time drivers, and what happens when a run fails inspection. A purely sales-led reply tends to stay general and redirect to price.
- Check who issues the export documents and who receives the money. A separate export agent is common and legitimate, but it should be disclosed. Undisclosed changes between quotation, contract and payment are the ones worth pausing on.
A 10-minute video audit script
Ask for a live call, not a recorded file, at a time you choose. Keep it short and ask for these four views in order:
- Outside: the building entrance and company sign, with the street visible
- Production floor: a slow continuous walk down the line, without cuts, showing people working
- Your product's equipment: the machine or process that would actually make your item, plus tooling or moulds
- Evidence in progress: raw material, work in progress, finished samples, and the packing area
While watching, ask: Who owns this machine? What is the current order running on this line? Where are rejected units kept? Which step takes the longest? What would you need to change to make my specification? An operator at the site usually answers differently from someone reading a sales sheet.
Subject: Short live video call about [product] — [your order / PI number] Hello [name], Before we confirm the order, could we arrange a 10-minute live video call at your production site this week? Please show, in one continuous walk: 1. The building entrance and company sign. 2. The production line currently running. 3. The equipment that would make [product]. 4. Samples and the packing area. We would also like to ask a few short questions about the process during the call. Please confirm the date, time and the name of the person we will speak with. Thank you. [your name / company]
Red flags: a pre-recorded video, a refusal to show the entrance, an empty workshop, a guide who will not let you choose where the camera goes, or answers that contradict the licence and the invoice.
When an in-person visit is worth it
A remote review is usually enough to connect documents, names and claims. An on-site visit becomes worth the cost when the order value is material, the product is custom, the equipment or capacity is central to the decision, subcontracting is suspected, or a relationship problem needs a person in the room.
A visit should end with a written record: what was seen, what could not be verified, photos, open questions and a clear recommendation. It should not promise that the supplier is safe or that future units will be defect-free.
Questions buyers usually ask
Is a trading company always a bad choice?
No. It can be useful for mixed-product orders, small quantities and consolidation. The risk is not knowing who makes the goods and who is accountable for quality.
Can a business licence prove a factory?
Not on its own. Business scope, registered address and the actual production site need to be compared; a licence does not show capacity or equipment.
What should a video audit include?
A live unedited walk-through of the entrance sign, the production area in operation, the equipment for your product, and samples or work in progress, with questions only an operator could answer.
Can an independent check guarantee the supplier is safe?
No. Checks gather evidence and expose open questions; they cannot eliminate commercial risk or replace legal, certification or laboratory advice.